Using Explicit Thresholds were valuable for judging Benefits and Harms in partially contextualized GRADE Guidelines.

OBJECTIVES: Guideline panels must assess the magnitude of health benefits and harms to develop sensible recommendations. However, they rarely use explicit thresholds. In this paper we report on the piloting and the use thresholds for benefits and harms. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We piloted the use of thresholds in a Chilean COVID-19 living guideline. For each of the critical outcomes, we asked panelists to suggest values of the thresholds for large, moderate, small, or trivial or no effect. We collected this information through a survey and an on-line discussion. RESULTS: Twelve panelists decided on thresholds for three critical outcomes (mortality, need for mechanical ventilation and serious adverse events). For all outcomes, an absolute risk reduction was considered larger with more than 50 events, moderate with less than 50 events, small with less than 25 events, and trivial with less than 10 events. Having these a priori thresholds in place significantly impacted on the development of recommendations. CONCLUSION: Explicit thresholds were a valuable addition to the judgment of the certainty in the evidence, to decide the direction and strength of the recommendation and to evaluate the need for update. We believe this is a line of research worth perusing.

Dietas basadas en plantas y factores de riesgo cardio-metabólicos. ¿Qué dice la evidencia?

RESUMEN Las dietas basadas en plantas (DBP) se caracterizan por una alta ingesta de alimentos de origen vegetal y evitan parcial o totalmente los productos animales. El objetivo de esta revisión fue recopilar evidencia sobre DBP, sus tipos y su efecto en principales factores de riesgo cardio-metabólicos (FRCM) modificables. Se encontró que existen DBP saludables y no saludables. Algunas DBP saludables son: vegetariana, mediterránea y DASH (sigla en inglés de la dieta Enfoques Alimenticios para Detener la Hipertensión). Estas promueven la ingesta de alimentos de origen vegetal "saludables" (frutas, verduras, legumbres, semillas, frutos secos, cereales integrales, palta, aceite de oliva y/o canola) y, una reducción gradual de todos los alimentos de origen animal, especialmente carnes rojas y procesadas; evitando alimentos de origen vegetal "menos saludables" (cereales refinados, fritos, productos de pastelería, alimentos con azúcar añadido). Las DBP no saludables, se caracterizan por una alta ingesta de estos alimentos "menos saludables", y se asocian con mayor riesgo cardiovascular, por el bajo aporte de antioxidantes, micronutrientes, fibra dietética y grasas insaturadas. DBP saludables pueden disminuir el riesgo de diabetes tipo 2, hipertensión arterial, sobrepeso y obesidad. Han mostrado mayores beneficios cardiovasculares en comparación con dietas tradicionales, reduciendo significativamente: HbA1c y glicemia en ayunas en diabéticos; presión arterial sistólica y diastólica en hipertensos y prehipertensos; índice de masa corporal en sujetos con sobrepeso/obesidad y mejorando el perfil lipídico en sujetos con dislipidemia. Patrones de DBP saludables, como el tipo vegetariano, mediterráneo y DASH son recomendadas para prevenir y tratar los FRCM.

ABSTRACT Plant-based diets (PBD) are characterized by a high intake of foods of plant origin and the partial or total avoidance of animal products. The objective of the current study was to compile the evidence on types of PBD and its effect on the main modifiable cardio-metabolic risk factors (CMRF). Healthy and unhealthy PBD were found to exist. Some healthy PBDs were: vegetarian, mediterranean and DASH (Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension). These promote the intake of "healthy" plant-based foods (fruits, vegetables, legumes, seeds, nuts, whole grains, avocado, olive oil and / or canola) and a gradual reduction of all foods of animal origin, especially red and processed meats; avoiding "less healthy" plant-based foods (refined, fried cereals, pastry products, foods with added sugar). Unhealthy PBDs were characterized by a high intake of these "less healthy" foods, and are associated with greater cardiovascular risk, due to the low contribution of antioxidants, micronutrients, dietary fiber and unsaturated fats. Healthy PBDs can lower the risk of type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, being overweight, and obesity. They have shown greater cardiovascular benefits compared to traditional diets, significantly reducing: HbA1c and fasting glycemia in diabetics; systolic and diastolic blood pressure in hypertensive and prehypertensive patients; body mass index in overweight / obese subjects and improves lipid profile in subjects with dyslipidemia. Healthy PBD patterns, such as vegetarian, Mediterranean, and DASH are recommended to prevent and treat CMRF.